Tier Strategy Guide
Design an effective tier structure for your loyalty program
A well-designed tier structure motivates customers to spend more while rewarding your best customers appropriately.
Tier Design Principles
1. Make the First Upgrade Achievable
The jump from base tier to the first upgrade should feel attainable:
Too high: Customers give up before reaching it
Too low: No sense of achievement
Sweet spot: 2-3x your average order value
2. Create Meaningful Differences
Each tier should feel noticeably better:
Cashback rates should increase significantly (not just 0.5%)
Consider 1.5-2x multipliers between tiers
3. Keep It Simple
3-4 tiers is optimal
More than 5 tiers creates confusion
Use clear, memorable names
Tier Structure Examples
Standard E-commerce Store
Best for: General retail, fashion, home goods
Bronze
$0
2%
Entry tier for all customers
Silver
$300
4%
Achievable after 3-4 orders
Gold
$1,000
6%
Loyal customer recognition
Platinum
$2,500
10%
VIP status, exclusive
Premium/Luxury Brand
Best for: High AOV stores, luxury goods
Member
$0
1%
Base tier
Preferred
$1,000
3%
Regular customers
Elite
$5,000
5%
Significant spenders
VIP
$15,000
8%
Top customers
Subscription/Consumables
Best for: Repeat purchase products, subscriptions
Starter
$0
3%
Higher base rate
Regular
$200
5%
Quick first upgrade
Loyal
$500
7%
Consistent buyers
Champion
$1,000
10%
Brand advocates
Budget-Conscious Store
Best for: Discount retailers, high-volume low-margin
Basic
$0
1%
Minimal base reward
Plus
$150
2%
Easy first tier
Premium
$400
3%
Regular shoppers
Setting Thresholds
Based on Average Order Value (AOV)
Use your AOV to set achievable thresholds:
$30-50
$150-250
$500-800
$50-100
$250-400
$1,000-1,500
$100-200
$400-600
$1,500-3,000
$200+
$600-1,000
$2,500-5,000
Based on Customer Distribution
Look at your existing customer spending:
First upgrade: Top 30-40% of customers should qualify
Second tier: Top 10-15% of customers
Top tier: Top 2-5% of customers
Setting Cashback Rates
Calculating Sustainable Rates
Your cashback should be funded by:
Increased customer retention
Higher average order values
More frequent purchases
Rule of thumb: Total cashback should be < 50% of your profit margin
20%
Up to 8%
40%
Up to 15%
60%+
Up to 20%
Rate Progression Examples
Conservative (safe for low margins)
Standard (balanced)
Aggressive (high margins, competitive market)
Evaluation Period Strategy
Annual Evaluation
Spending resets each year
Customers must maintain spending to keep tier
Creates urgency and ongoing engagement
Best for: Most stores
Lifetime Evaluation
Spending accumulates forever
Customers never lose progress
Simpler to understand
Best for: New programs, relationship-focused brands
Common Mistakes to Avoid
❌ Too Many Tiers
Problem: 6+ tiers confuse customers Solution: Stick to 3-4 tiers maximum
❌ Unreachable Top Tier
Problem: $50,000 threshold when AOV is $50 Solution: Top tier should be achievable by your best 2-5% of customers
❌ Tiny Rate Differences
Problem: 2% → 2.5% → 3% feels meaningless Solution: Make each tier noticeably better (at least 1.5x)
❌ Forgetting Your Margins
Problem: 20% cashback on 15% margin products Solution: Calculate sustainable rates before setting them
Tier Naming Best Practices
Metal/Gem Themes
Bronze → Silver → Gold → Platinum
Ruby → Sapphire → Emerald → Diamond
Status Themes
Member → Preferred → Elite → VIP
Basic → Plus → Premium → Ultimate
Brand-Aligned Names
Use names that match your brand voice
Consider your product/industry
Make them memorable
Next Steps
Create Your First Tier - Build your tier structure
Initial Data Sync - Import historical data
Review Business Metrics for ROI tracking
Last updated